Dollar General $DG ( ▲ 0.8% ) dominates small-town America with over 20,600 stores serving underserved rural markets. The company generated $40.6 billion in revenue in 2024, but faces significant margin compression (operating margins fell from 8.8% to 4.2% over three years). While the defensive business model serving essential goods remains sound, the investment thesis hinges on management's ability to stabilize margins around 4% through operational improvements. At current levels, DG appears reasonably valued for those believing in the turnaround story, but offers limited margin for error.

Meet the Uniswap web app — your hub for swapping, bridging, and buying crypto across Ethereum and 14 additional networks.

Access thousands of tokens and move assets between chains, all from a single, easy-to-use interface.

Trusted by millions, Uniswap includes real-time token warnings to help you avoid risky tokens, along with transparent pricing and open-source, audited contracts.

Whether you're exploring new tokens, bridging across networks, or making your first swap, Uniswap keeps onchain trading simple and secure.

Just connect your wallet to get started.

Get Started

Think of Dollar General as the convenience store that ate a grocery store and decided to have babies across rural America. With over 20,600 stores scattered across 48 states (and now Mexico!), DG has mastered the art of being exactly where you need them when you need toilet paper at 9 PM on a Tuesday.

Dollar General operates small-format discount stores averaging about 7,500 square feet—roughly the size of a large house. Their genius lies in the "Save time. Save money. Every day!" promise. While Walmart makes you hike through aircraft hangar-sized stores, DG lets you grab milk, bread, and cleaning supplies without needing a GPS.

Their revenue comes from selling four main categories:

Notice how consumables keep growing as a percentage? That's because when money gets tight, people still need shampoo and dog food, but they can skip the new throw pillows.

DG's competitive advantage is location, location, location—but not in the fancy real estate way. About 80% of their stores sit in towns with fewer than 20,000 people. These are places where the nearest Walmart might be 30 minutes away, making DG the hero of small-town America.

They combine national brands with their own private label products, often offering the store brand at "substantial discounts" to national brands. It's like having a generic drug strategy but for everything from cereal to cleaning supplies.

The company has achieved positive same-store sales growth every year since 1990, except 2021 (which followed the weird pandemic shopping boom of 2020). That's a pretty impressive streak that would make even the Yankees jealous.

Dollar General sits in a fascinating competitive position—they're simultaneously competing with everyone and no one. Their direct competitors include Family Dollar and Dollar Tree, but they also duke it out with Walmart, Target, grocery chains, and even pharmacies like CVS.

Here's where it gets interesting: DG is the largest discount retailer in the US by store count. Not by revenue (Walmart wins that), but by sheer number of locations. It's like being the McDonald's of discount retail—ubiquitous and convenient.

The competitive environment is "intense" (management's word, not ours), and it's getting more so. Some competitors are closing stores while others are expanding into DG's territory. The company notes that online retailers are also applying pressure, though their focus on immediate-need consumables provides some protection against the Amazon freight train.

DG's defensive moat comes from serving markets that larger retailers often ignore. When you're the only game in town (or one of very few), you've got pricing power and customer loyalty that's hard to replicate.

While DG doesn't break out specific market share data, their consistent store growth (725 new stores in 2024) and same-store sales increases suggest they're holding their own. However, the shift toward consumables and away from higher-margin categories like home goods indicates customers are becoming more selective—a sign of both economic pressure and competitive dynamics.

DG generated $40.6 billion in revenue in 2024 (↗️ 5.0% from 2023), but the story gets more interesting when you dig into the details:

By Category:

The trend is clear: customers are focusing on necessities. This is both good news (recession-resistant) and challenging news (lower margins).

DG's core customers are value-conscious shoppers, particularly low and fixed-income households. Think of them as serving people who need to make every dollar count. These customers might do their big shopping at Walmart but hit DG for fill-in trips and immediate needs.

The company notes their customers "continue to feel constrained in the current macroeconomic environment" with elevated expenses for rent, healthcare, energy, and food. Translation: their customers are getting squeezed, which affects spending on non-essentials.

Here's where things get a bit ugly:

That's a concerning trend. The margin compression comes from several factors:

Our DCF analysis suggests DG might be trading at a discount to its intrinsic value, but let's break down what we have to believe for that to be true.

The model assumes revenue growth starting at 5.0% in Year 1 (matching 2024's performance) and gradually declining to 2.9% by Year 5. This reflects:

Revenue Projections:

DCF Implied Share Price: $95.51

This assumes:

The valuation is quite sensitive to assumptions:

Terminal Growth Rate Sensitivity:

Discount Rate Sensitivity:

The DCF suggests a small potential upside if DG can stabilize margins and maintain modest growth. However, the key assumption—that operating margins will stop declining and stabilize around 4%—is doing a lot of heavy lifting in this model. If margins continue to compress, the fair value could be significantly lower.

For DG to succeed long-term, you need to believe:

The risks that could derail the investment:

Dollar General is a fascinating case study in retail resilience meeting modern challenges. The business model is fundamentally sound—serving underserved markets with essential goods is a time-tested strategy. The consistent same-store sales growth since 1990 (minus the pandemic year) speaks to the durability of their approach.

However, the margin compression over the past three years is concerning and represents the key investment risk. If DG can't stabilize margins around 4%, the investment thesis falls apart quickly. The company is essentially betting they can improve operations faster than costs rise—a challenging proposition in today's environment.

The valuation appears reasonable if you believe in the turnaround story, but there's limited margin for error. This isn't a "set it and forget it" investment—it requires monitoring quarterly results to see if the operational improvements are taking hold.

Bottom line: DG could be a solid investment for those who believe in the defensive retail thesis and management's ability to execute operational improvements. But if you're looking for a growth story, you might want to shop elsewhere. 🛒

AI-written, human-approved

Disclaimer: This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice, investment recommendations, or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities. The information contained in this report has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but StrataFinance does not guarantee its accuracy, completeness, or timeliness.